Operational Issues Caused by Incorrect Heat Exchanger Design Choices
OPERATIONAL ISSUES CAUSED BY WRONG DESIGN CHOICES FOR HEAT EXCHANGERS
Les Jackowski 1, * & Bob Whitsitt 2
1 Chevron Energy Technology Company, Richmond, California 94802, USA
2 Chevron Energy Technology Company, Houston, Texas 77002, USA
* Address all correspondence to: Les Jackowski, Chevron Energy Technology Company, 100 Chevron Way, Richmond, CA 94802, USA; E-mail: ljau@chevron.com
Failure of heat exchangers installed in industrial facilities may lead to serious accidents resulting in injuries, environmental spills, and significant financial losses. The purpose of this section is to discuss various design choices that may work properly for most typical operations but fail when heat exchangers operate at unexpected operating conditions which were not considered at the design stage. In this section, five different design choices that could lead to serious operational problems are described in detail:
- Selecting design temperatures for the heat exchangers installed in networks that are subject to non-uniform fouling (Sec. A)
- Selecting design temperatures for electric process heaters (Sec. B)
- Selecting fixed tubesheet heat exchangers without considering all possible operating cases (Sec. C)
- Selecting conventional heat exchanger geometry for cycling services and high tube-side temperature increase (Sec. D)
- Selecting the tube bundle geometry resulting in unforeseen flow-induced vibration tube failures (Sec. E).
Several industrial case studies are used to illustrate the key messages of each section and to highlight some of the limitations in the current methodologies, accepted practices, and industry standards in heat exchanger design. Moreover, it is shown that selecting designs that avoid operational issues do not necessarily result in the more expensive solutions.
NOMENCLATURE
API | American Petroleum Institute |
API RP | American Petroleum Institute Recommended Practice |
ASME | American Society of Mechanical Engineers |
BPVC | Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code |
ho | heat transfer coefficient of process fluid surrounding tubes or heating elements, W/m2 K |
HTHA | high-temperature hydrogen attack |
HTS | high-temperature sulfidation |
HTRIⓇ | Heat Transfer Research Inc. |
NHT | naphtha hydrotreater |
PFD | process flow diagram |
PWHT | Post weld heat treatment |
q | heat flux, W/m2 |
Rf | overall fouling resistance combining tube-side and shell-side fouling resistances, m2 K/W |
TAN | total acid number |
TEMA | Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers Association |
Tbulk | bulk temperature of process fluid, °C |
Twall | temperature of the tube wall in the shell-and-tube heat exchangers or sheath temperature in the electric process heaters, °C |
Uclean | overall heat transfer coefficient at clean conditions, W/m2 K |
Uobserved | overall heat transfer coefficient observed during operation, W/m2 K |
... You need a subscriptionOpen in a new tab. to view the full text of the article. If you already have the subscription, please login here